A company enters Chapter 11 with a $50 million superpriority DIP facility (unsecured), $10 million in other administrative claims, $200 million of pre‑petition first‑lien secured debt (collateral valued at $250 million), and $100 million of general unsecured claims. If the enterprise value is $280 million, compute recoveries for every class and state which class is the fulcrum.
AdvancedModel answer
The waterfall:
- Pre‑petition first‑lien secured claim: paid from its collateral. Collateral value $250M exceeds the $200M claim, so they receive $200M in full. No deficiency claim.
Remaining enterprise value after collateral distribution = $280M - $200M = $80M of unencumbered estate value.
-
Administrative claims (including the DIP superpriority) total $60M ($50M DIP + $10M other). These are paid from unencumbered value ahead of general unsecured claims. They receive full payment of $60M, leaving $20M.
-
General unsecured claims of $100M: receive the remaining $20M, or a 20% recovery.
Equity receives nothing. The fulcrum security is the general unsecured claims, as they are the class where value runs out.
Follow-up pressure:
- How would the answer differ if the DIP had been granted a priming lien on the first‑lien collateral? (The DIP would then take a portion of the collateral before the pre‑petition first‑lien, likely reducing the first‑lien recovery.)
- If the collateral value had been only $180 million, how does the waterfall change and which class becomes the fulcrum?
- Why might the unsecured creditors’ committee challenge the DIP facility if it includes a roll‑up of the pre‑petition debt, even if the arithmetic appears to work?
This is an advanced Superday-level question with a full model answer, part of IB Atlas's practice bank.
Start freeRelated topics
- A debtor in possession seeks approval of a $120 million DIP facility that will prime the pre‑petition first‑lien lender’s $300 million claim. The first‑lien lender objects, arguing adequate protection is impossible because the collateral is worth only $250 million. What must the debtor demonstrate to obtain the priming lien, and how can it structure the DIP to overcome the objection?
- Compare a pre‑packaged Chapter 11 filing to a traditional free‑fall Chapter 11. Under what circumstances is a pre‑pack infeasible, forcing a company into a contested Chapter 11 proceeding?
- The Second Circuit’s *Momentive* decision addressed the enforceability of make‑whole premiums in bankruptcy. What is the general rule regarding make‑whole premiums when a debtor repays debt ahead of schedule in Chapter 11, and why do creditors often lose their claim to such premiums?
- In a Chapter 11 case, a debtor proposes to sell substantially all assets under Section 363. A stalking‑horse bidder has agreed to pay $500 million in cash, and the secured lender plans to credit bid its $450 million claim. How does a credit bid work, and what protections exist for other bidders and creditors? What are the risks for unsecured creditors?
- A distressed company is considering an out‑of‑court exchange but runs into the holdout problem: the indenture requires 100% consent to change payment terms, and holdouts could sue. Analyze the trade‑offs between initiating a pre‑packaged Chapter 11 and proceeding with a pure out‑of‑court exchange with exit consents. Assume the company has NOLs that would be limited under Section 382 if an ownership change occurs.